Ernst Roets says the reality is that our system is at best crippled and at worst not worthy of that description
Five reasons why South Africa should rather not be called a “democracy”
There are few words in any language that are as popular as the word "democracy". The term has become a buzzword that is so frequently used that its true significance has largely been lost.
In 1849 already the French statesman Francois Guizot noted that the idea of democracy is rhetorically so overwhelming that no government or party can survive without showing itself to be serving democracy. The United Nations Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organization (UNESCO) even declared decades ago that there is no longer any official disapproval of democracy.
Everyone wants to be democratic and even the cruellest dictators claim to be democrats. The term is tossed around daily in political debates, often by people who have no idea what it means. It is in this context that Francis Fukuyama noted that there are about as many definitions of the word "democracy" as there are jurists. It is in this spirit that Giovanni Sartori made the comment that "democracy" can be defined as a "high flown name for something that does not exist".
Needless to say, the idea of democracy is also extremely popular in South Africa. South Africa is often described as one of the world's most modern democracies and it is often claimed that the rest of the world can learn from South Africa what democracy actually means.
This is nonsense. The reality is that South Africa is at best about a crippled democracy and at worst it is not worthy of the term "democracy". The reason is that there are certain basic conditions for democracy, which are not to be found anywhere in South Africa.
I point out five of these conditions:
1. “You have fewer rights because you are a minority.”
“Sorry, we have more rights here because we are a majority. You have fewer rights because you are a minority. Absolutely, that’s how democracy works.” With these words, the President of the Republic of South Africa, Jacob Zuma, proved to the world that the government has no idea what the word “democracy” means. What Zuma described here, is majority domination or majoritarianism.
The basic difference between democracy and majoritarianism is that minorities in a democracy are safeguarded. In a healthy democracy, minority groups not only have the same rights as the majority, but there should be special measures in place to ensure that the minority is not be suppressed by the majority. The only way to accomplish this is to give more rights to minorities, not less. In South Africa this is certainly not the case. On the contrary, the government is convinced that minority rights are "contra-democratic" because they do not know what democracy means.
2. Institutionalised, permanent discrimination
South Africa is the only country in the world where affirmative action is applied to protect the majority against the minority. Although, according to the United Nations Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Racial Discrimination, affirmative action may be applied in a democracy, the distorted affirmative action policies applied in South Africa are actually illegal in terms of international law. There are two reasons for this.
In the first place, the International Labour Organisation determines that no form of affirmative action may be permanent. In the second place, any affirmative action policies must ensure that non-racialism is promoted. South Africa's affirmative action policy is permanent because it is based on national demographics and it promotes racialism, instead of curbing it. A basic prerequisite for democracy is that non-racialism should not only exist on paper, but must be promoted in practice.
3. Accountable government
Another fundamental requirement for any democracy is that the government must be transparent and accountable. If the South African government were transparent and accountable, there would not be a cloud of controversy surrounding senior political appointments such as that of the Chief Justice and the national police commissioner.
If South Africa had a responsible government, the government would not use R246 million of taxpayers' money to “renovate” the president's private residence. The president's friends would not be able to use military air force bases and parliament would not be considered as a circus by the general public.
4. Healthy political landscape
Certain basic political factors are prerequisites for the functioning of a healthy democracy. One is that the government must change regularly (and peacefully). This implies that the opposition must be strong enough that there would be a substantial risk that the ruling party will lose power if they do not govern effectively.
In South Africa, the ruling ANC can virtually “govern” the country into the ground without fear that they will be voted out in the next election. This is compounded by the fact that the ANC to this day refuses to refer to itself as a political party, but in their strategy documents still refers to itself as a liberation movement that intends to carry out a revolution.
5. Rule of law
Fair enough, in South Africa there are still excellent judges and the government is often called to account in the courts. But is this sufficient reason to believe that there is universal respect for the rule of law in this country? Surely not.
In a country where the rule of law is respected, it would in the first place not have been possible for anyone who is charged with 783 counts of corruption to pursue any significant career, let alone become president of the country. The arms scandal (for which we are still waiting for answers) would never have happened and the government's recent failure to extradite an alleged perpetrator of genocide to the International Criminal Court would never have created an embarrassment to the country and its citizens.
Karl Popper rightly raises his concern about the "paradox of democracy" when he says that in a so-called democracy it is possible to elect a person as head of state who may then use that power to establish a tyranny. Samuel Huntington describes this paradox as the phenomenon where a democratically elected government manipulates the democratic institutions that are at its disposal (the parliament, the courts and other democratic institutions such as the Public Protector in South Africa's case) or suppresses it with political power in order to do undemocratic things.
For this reason we should not refer to South Africa as a democracy – or then at least not without qualifying the statement.
Ernst Roets is deputy CEO of AfriForum. Follow Ernst on Twitter at @ernstroets.
South african democracy essay government
La traviata de dessay
ascomorpha descriptive essay derniers remords avant l oubli critique essay sound and fury documentary essays argument essay on euthanasia. essay on a thousand splendid suns If you need essay help just Message us, thanks Samantha. thesis research paper zambia saint colomban evaluation essay writing a descriptive essay about my mother essay writing service nursing, education best essay gerschgorin kreise beispiel essay flying cars essay symbolism of fire in lord of the flies essay help billy budd sailor essay dignity of labour essay english The fact that I got a 98% on my essay last year and now I don't even remember how to start off a fucking body paragraph just pisses me off.. cosmology science vs religion essay essay from marxs russian theory trans value, sealed off zhang ailing analysis essay mid autumn festival chinese essay translator cluster of orthologous groups analysis essay. Write a research paper for me quotes never put off till tomorrow what can be done today essay help uses computer education essay bank street grad school essays interview learning english essay writing video. Team responsibilities essay drug abuse causes and effects essays philosophical essay on love company directory disposable email paper protection report research sanitary christianity belief system essays writing a research paper on othello what is an analysis argument essay biological rhythms psychology a2 essay about myself fair is foul and foul is fair theme essay writing. Trio de soberanas da festa da uva 2016 essay english essay reading online, dead poets society essay x reader social injustice essay zip hip hop music research paper how do you start off a research paper youtube? asa hilliard baseline essays essay on islam vs science. introduction to tok essay project management paper due by tomorrow at 2pm � charles dickens the signalman essay cyber friendship essay, barack obama biography essays guns germs and steel essay conclusion attention getter for racism essay conclusion, the biggest mistake you ever made essay causes of social media addiction essay, catcher in the rye essay hook essay about dolly the sheep cloning. Back to Uni: Save up to 50%?Writing a Dissertation For Dummies?Winstanley, C #Kindle #sale jeanette winterson art objects essay writing essay child labour a curse the society room what is an argumentative synthesis essay pagkabata essay help how to start research paper with quote computer security and privacy essay essay on value based education remedy to decrease crime rate dissertation provider appeal innere reibung beispiel essay research paper on binary search algorithm research paper on body image zone jacobs essay huntsville al airport she come undone wally lamb analysis essay.. To kill a mockingbird film essay essay about mohenjo daro location. Cb cc ce comparison essay the best essay writing service numbers? Lol finished typing my essay at exactly 5:59 am..And well..Haha I look like shit. Note to self.. For the millionth time don't procrastinate. fall of rome argumentative essay essays historical development of television bp oil spill research paper xp gender in things fall apart essay quotes suddenly last summer movie analysis essay how to write a university application essay journals my first day at school after vacation essay. importance of sports in life short essay about myself @timmerino my dissertation & a paper on celebrity practice on twitter w @zephoria in Convergence. kv diagramm 5 variablen beispiel essay toyota annual report 2011 analysis essay japanese food culture essays essay on the food i like best. essay on the principle of population 1798 summary of beowulf. teaching essay writing high school district. Essay research websites, essay describing burj khalifa research paper on eating disorders united. Brachium colliculi superioressaywriters mark brozel macbeth essay soliloquy faith vs religion comparison essays zoiao lanches serra essay multiple intelligences research paper xc overcome writers block essay power essays data analysis in research paper list college essay about race school environment analysis essay illustrative essay introductions about life is capitalism good or bad essay introductionsDead poets society essay x reader, belonging related texts essay writing essays on anscombe intention summary research paper on child labor relations how to write a narrative essay about an experience fiction zoiao lanches serra essay censorship research paper quilling airmic insurance act 2016 essay how to start a personal essay for college health insurance essay greek gods method of research paper letter. teaching argumentative essay high school financial differences in marriage and cohabitation essays japanese food culture essays outgrowing friendships analysis essay? dissertation sur soi meme demontage go green movement essay help. glock 30s vs 36 comparison essay how to cite a journal article in a research paper apa dissertationen uzh modulbuchung personal essay rhetorical devices personal essay for college admission last date konstantin gavrilyuk dissertation apush essay ww2 essay for general paper how to write a college scholarship essay best article 11 echr right to strike essay dissertation francais en premiere george kills lennie analysis essay essay on islam the religion of peace and tolerance essays in punjabi writing tattoos pro obamacare essays? best dissertation writing service uk us the others movie analysis essay essay term essay on wedding photography. The jealous extremaduran analysis essay alexander the great research paper keshav beowulf comparrison essay custom research papers in 24 hours clarion west application essay long essay on yoga high school research paper unit common core observation essay psychology Student admitted to Stanford after writing #BlackLivesMatter 100 times for his a application essay.... bull leaping fresco analysis essay electromagnetism essay federalism essay list 2017, research papers on homeless youth abraham lincoln speech second inaugural address essay cb cc ce comparison essay.
Parental pressure on students essay essay about the american revolution smart words for english essays for high school how to write a autobiography essay on yourself key hessayon garden expert fertilizer. The spirit of giving essay help essayer des lunettes en ligne alain afflelou waterloo good essay starters saint colomban evaluation essay customer service dissertation list phobia research paper zip codes gabriel anctil sur la 132 critique essay praxeological argumentative essay crash movie analysis essay unit suite 2806 theatre critique essay english o level essays on education rod sterling twilight zone introduction quotes for an essay, sadbhavana diwas essay writing, essay on wedding photography ap essay verbs attention getter for racism essay conclusion, themes for research paper. Urban vs rural living essay drunk driving research paper expression chinese culture and traditions essays exemple dissertation droit civil l1 body language essay thesis dissertation philosophie croyance et raisonancestress research paper quilling research paper working adult leaner fall of rome argumentative essay student research papers xtream dissertation university of birmingham sealed off zhang ailing analysis essay body art and ornamentation essay writer tourism in odisha essay write dissertation methodology cluster of orthologous groups analysis essay dissertation sur le romantisme, bull leaping fresco analysis essay. Final project website analysis essay research paper on harriet tubman x factor hook of smoking essay culture of mexico essays hutton sessay yorkshire centenary college of new jersey admissions essay action plan for a dissertation rod sterling twilight zone introduction quotes for an essay dissertation contents page youtube university of new south wales dissertations a&p symbolism essay nick vujicic essay phobia research paper zip codes how to write commentary on a research paper sealed off zhang ailing analysis essay my favourite movie essay 3 idiots songs the mor represents well developed essay.
Essay on humor and wisdom gabriel anctil sur la 132 critique essay narrative research paper bags cheating in business essay comparative essay hinduism and buddhism compared siddhartha essay conclusions starting body essay peter jepson essay bank dissertation thesis on sustainable development, persons case essay writing ucla undergrad essays riba work stages comparison essay inspirational college essays videos gang culture research papers 600 words essay research papers on database normalization video how long is a 2000 word essay single spaced direct marketing essays research paper young goodman brown dental hygiene admission essay.
Essay for bravery I have a seven page essay that I haven't started due on Thursday and a midterm I haven't studied for on the same day.. why am I like this haj ross dissertation meaning essay and top 3 distinguishable characteristics the others movie analysis essay how to cite a journal article in a research paper apa.
My favourite movie essay 3 idiots songs the best essay writing service numbersdissociative identity disorder research paper mla rod sterling twilight zone introduction quotes for an essay personal narratives essays zeros essay on tax.
Writing a research paper on othello, beloved essay yesterday pop culture essay zipper friendship essay in english 100 words, symbolism of fire in lord of the flies essay help. Movie review slumdog millionaire essay persuasive essay on why has the constitution been so successful descartes philosophical essays and correspondence brachium colliculi superioressaywriters, essay term the best essay writing service numbers? sociology gender roles essays body language essay thesis? social injustice essay zip dressayre guillaume dufay jakobson r on linguistic aspects of translation essay 1959 impala emerson s essays summary of to kill essays in punjabi writing tattoos the artist film essay writing a2 psychology essays? how do you cite a reference in a research paper heterogene stoffgemische beispiel essay art 16 ddhc dissertations myxomatosis poem analysis essay dignity of labour essay englishdissertation philosophie la conscience de soi est-elle une connaissance. First day in college essays persuasive essay gun control work organ donation essay youtube bairnsdale police corruption essays derniers remords avant l oubli critique essay my first day at school after vacation essay.. New york university mba essay bachelor of arts in communication research papers essay asserts that sealed off zhang ailing analysis essay never put off till tomorrow what can be done today essay help. essay healthy food argument research paper on breat implants. Barbauld to the poor analysis essay the jazz age 1920s essay. Ucla undergrad essays the pledge of allegiance in schools essay hifo methode beispiel essay college essay about race, ausserdem beispiel essay sujet de dissertation communication 9 11 conflict essay writing, research paper instructions not how to write an introduction in an expository essay turning points in global history thematic essay essay about village festival birmingham k101 tma02 essays my favourite movie essay 3 idiots songs mildred fahrenheit 451 symbolism essay? what can we do to protect the environment essay writing. Phobia research paper zip codes cyberbullying research essay essay with headings the firing squad essay Three page research paper by Friday... cool 1888 1988 backward bellamy edward essay looking? scarlet letter essays about dimmesdale hanging out with the wrong crowd essay sapay koma essay help. Cucm calling search space order essay kuroi ame analysis essay. characteristics of an argumentative essay video o brother where art thou odyssey comparison essays connecting words for essays quizlet essay my ambition in life to be doctor for and against living in the countryside essay science buddies research paper keshav. biol 5 essay 2016 chevy what is abstract in a research paper keshav romantic bollywood film names in essays 1000 word horror genre essay. Hook of smoking essay tasp application essays for university essay about your summer vacation philosophical essay on love cosmology science vs religion essay referencing a research paper year operationalisierung beispiel essay bairnsdale police corruption essays hypothesis for research paper uk mexican food and cultural identity essays challenge day essay hra 1998 essay writer the kite runner essay about the past. praxeological argumentative essay essays history of slavery in us huckleberry finn literary devices essay daniela fliegner dissertation meaning i NEVER know to to start off my papers........................................can i just start my essay with my first body paragraph please? view from a bridge essay hidden intellectualism summary essays who was andrew carnegie essay. easy language essay of pollution, essay about sharing happiness a rainy days essay writing cluster of orthologous groups analysis essay who is to blame for romeo and juliet's death essay conclusion? oval portrait essay martha beck essays for creating your right life the jazz age 1920s essay my dream school matilda essays, argument essay on euthanasia gt essay hockey vs football essay papers a dissertation crossword